James Ratliff - The Human Stain

The Human Stain is a mystery-drama film from 2003 based on Philip Roth's novel of the same name. Set in New England during the late nineties, the film follows the narration of Nathan Zuckerman, a down-and-out writer telling the story of his friend, the recently disgraced professor Coleman Silk, after he and his lover, Athena College janitor Faunia Farley, are killed under suspicious circumstances in a car crash. The film tackles a variety of contemporary social and moral issues surrounding the late nineties including academic politics, race relations, trauma, and abuse through the lens of Zuckerman's reflections, Silk's budding romance, and flashbacks to Silk's youth.

Silk and Farley in their last moments before their car crashes.

Young Silk first sees Steena Paulsson at the library.

So what?

The Human Stain received mixed reviews with critics not lambasting the movie but calling it mediocre and passable. Most people seemed confused by the choice of casting especially in regards to Coleman Silk and to a lesser extent Faunia Farley despite the consensus that their actors gave decent performances. At the time, many people argued over its polarizing subplot about political correctness regarding it as either overly preachy or too subtle. Roger Ebert praised the movie for its vulnerable character studies, saying "Here are complex, troubled, flawed people, brave enough to breathe deeply and take one more risk with their lives." Regardless of its reception, the film stands as interesting artefact about new aims in filmmaking toward the blurred lines of identity to a more mainstream audience and the surrounding conversation of its casting and whitewashing in the American film industry.

Discussion Questions:

1. Does the choice of casting of Coleman Silk in this film affect the audience's perception of its themes?

2. Coleman Silk never reveals that he passed most of his life as a Jew until the very end of his life. What could finally finally prompt him to reveal his identity to Farley and not anyone else in his life?

Comments

Everything, Everything - Ellie Marmoll

The film Everything, Everything , based on the novel by Nicola Yoon , follows the life of newly eighteen-year-old Madeline living with a rare autoimmune dis ease that prevents her from leaving the protection of her sealed home in which she is iso lated from the outside world. Maddy is extremely imaginative, especially when Olly moves in next door and her curiosity for life outside of her home grows, causing her to push the boundaries that formerly kept her safe. With the bond that they had formed with their limited contact, the pair fall deeper in love, and over time Olly helps Maddy realize what she has been doing is not really living. Trailer The particular scene in this screenshot is the main turning point of the movie where things drastically begin to change. In this scene, Maddy takes a dramatic leap and decides to leave her house to go to Hawaii with Olly. She packed a bag an d purchased the tickets and accommodations,...

If Beale Street Could Talk -Olivia Backes

If Beale Street Could Talk, based on the novel by James Baldwin, is a romance/crime drama that follows a love story between Tish and Fonny as they become expecting parents while Fonny is wrongfully imprisoned for a crime he didn't commit. Audiences watch as their relationship and romance blossom as well as the dynamics of the different relationships and families of Tish and Fonny during this time of racial injustice and ways in which the judicial process failed Black communities on the basis of their rights and freedoms. This is a story about hope, dreams, and resilience. Fonny expresses joy on the street after he and Tish find somewhere to finally call home in Harlem Tish stands in front of Fonny as a shield between him and the police officer who is harassing Fonny for defending Tish after she was attacked in a store by a white man This film is significant because it tells a love story about the hopes and dreams of a young couple and their families who refuse to let their lives be...

David Priester - Dead Presidents

Dead Presidents is a 1995 American crime film based on the true story of Haywood T. Kirkland, about a Vietnam War veteran who is forced to commit a heist after he’s no longer able to support his girlfriend or daughter. The film spans the better part of a decade, starting at the end of the main character’s (Anthony) high school life before covering his service overseas and then his tumultuous return home. The film is most well known for the heist scene that serves as the climax. Trailer Selected Screenshots After an argument with Juanita, his girlfriend, Anthony’s doubt in himself continues to grow. Anthony, disguised with face paint, waits to ambush the armored truck’s guards Cultural Significance The film portrays the struggles of veterans who lacked government support after coming back from the war. It also shows the supposed loss of innocence after Vietnam, directly comparing the post-war period after World War 2 to the far more jaded post-war period of t...

screeningblackliterature2023

Search This Blog