James Ratliff - The Human Stain

The Human Stain is a mystery-drama film from 2003 based on Philip Roth's novel of the same name. Set in New England during the late nineties, the film follows the narration of Nathan Zuckerman, a down-and-out writer telling the story of his friend, the recently disgraced professor Coleman Silk, after he and his lover, Athena College janitor Faunia Farley, are killed under suspicious circumstances in a car crash. The film tackles a variety of contemporary social and moral issues surrounding the late nineties including academic politics, race relations, trauma, and abuse through the lens of Zuckerman's reflections, Silk's budding romance, and flashbacks to Silk's youth.

Silk and Farley in their last moments before their car crashes.

Young Silk first sees Steena Paulsson at the library.

So what?

The Human Stain received mixed reviews with critics not lambasting the movie but calling it mediocre and passable. Most people seemed confused by the choice of casting especially in regards to Coleman Silk and to a lesser extent Faunia Farley despite the consensus that their actors gave decent performances. At the time, many people argued over its polarizing subplot about political correctness regarding it as either overly preachy or too subtle. Roger Ebert praised the movie for its vulnerable character studies, saying "Here are complex, troubled, flawed people, brave enough to breathe deeply and take one more risk with their lives." Regardless of its reception, the film stands as interesting artefact about new aims in filmmaking toward the blurred lines of identity to a more mainstream audience and the surrounding conversation of its casting and whitewashing in the American film industry.

Discussion Questions:

1. Does the choice of casting of Coleman Silk in this film affect the audience's perception of its themes?

2. Coleman Silk never reveals that he passed most of his life as a Jew until the very end of his life. What could finally finally prompt him to reveal his identity to Farley and not anyone else in his life?

Comments

Everything, Everything - Ellie Marmoll

The film Everything, Everything , based on the novel by Nicola Yoon , follows the life of newly eighteen-year-old Madeline living with a rare autoimmune dis ease that prevents her from leaving the protection of her sealed home in which she is iso lated from the outside world. Maddy is extremely imaginative, especially when Olly moves in next door and her curiosity for life outside of her home grows, causing her to push the boundaries that formerly kept her safe. With the bond that they had formed with their limited contact, the pair fall deeper in love, and over time Olly helps Maddy realize what she has been doing is not really living. Trailer The particular scene in this screenshot is the main turning point of the movie where things drastically begin to change. In this scene, Maddy takes a dramatic leap and decides to leave her house to go to Hawaii with Olly. She packed a bag an d purchased the tickets and accommodations,...

The Secret Life of Bees - Emery O

Synopsis: Set in the summer of 1964, right after the passing of the Civil Rights Act, The Secret Life of Bees follows Lily Owens as she runs away from her abusive father in hopes of finding out something about her late mother's life, leading her down a long road of self realization and discovery of the world. Through her journey she is forced to expand her point of view, address the issues of racism in her time and the importance of understanding lives other than your own. Lily spends time growing, bonding and healing with the Boatwright sisters, later finding out that her mother had also lived there many years in the past. Trailer: Screenshot #1: The pink house where Lily goes to seek out information about her late mother's life, and where she meets the Boatwright sisters. The house is revealed to be pink as part of a lesson to Lily. August tells her that she thought it was the "tackiest" color she had ever seen, but "if it'll lift May's heart, then...

His House -- Tristan Farmer

Film Summary: His House follows a refugee couple from South Sudan after they have been placed in government housing in England. Soon after moving in, it becomes apparent that the house is haunted, with both characters having individual spiritual encounters or hallucinations of the daughter they lost in their journey to England. The film follows both characters as they react to the haunting differently, with the husband, Bol, believing everything they brought from South Sudan is cursed and needs to be destroyed so they can create a new life in England; while the wife, Rial, believes they need to return to their homeland and atone for their sins. Film Significance: This film’s main purpose is to explore the mindset and experiences of refugees. The conflict between Bol and Rial’s reaction to their haunted house is a metaphor for how two immigrants or refugees might grapple with the question of assimilation and the struggle of culture shock. In this case, Bol repre...

screeningblackliterature2023

Search This Blog